J. P. Angel

Supporters Shield Winner 1

MLS Cup runner-up 1

MLS Cup Champion 1

2000

Aston Villa vs Coventry City 3:2

2001

Aston Villa vs FC Basel 1893 4:1

Aston Villa vs NK Varteks Varazdin 2:3

Southampton FC vs Aston Villa 1:3

Aston Villa vs Blackburn Rovers 2:0

Aston Villa vs Bolton Wanderers 3:2

Penalty

Aston Villa vs Ipswich Town 2:1

Derby County vs Aston Villa 3:1

Aston Villa vs Tottenham Hotspur 1:1

Penalty

Aston Villa vs Derby County 2:1

Charlton Athletic vs Aston Villa 1:2

Aston Villa vs West Ham United 2:1

Middlesbrough FC vs Aston Villa 2:1

2002

Aston Villa vs Fulham FC 3:1

Aston Villa vs Preston North End 5:0

Aston Villa vs Blackburn Rovers 1:4

2003

Aston Villa vs Leicester City 3:1

Manchester City vs Aston Villa 4:1

Wycombe Wanderers vs Aston Villa 0:5

Right-footed shot

Penalty

Left-footed shot

Aston Villa vs Bolton Wanderers 1:1

Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace 3:0

Aston Villa vs Wolverhampton Wanderers 3:2

Aston Villa vs Chelsea FC 2:1

Blackburn Rovers vs Aston Villa 0:2

Aston Villa vs Fulham FC 3:0

Aston Villa vs Portsmouth FC 2:1

Bolton Wanderers vs Aston Villa 5:2

Right-footed shot

Left-footed shot

Aston Villa vs Leeds United 2:0

Penalty

Fulham FC vs Aston Villa 1:2

Wolverhampton Wanderers vs Aston Villa 0:4

Aston Villa vs Manchester City 1:1

Aston Villa vs Tottenham Hotspur 1:0

Southampton FC vs Aston Villa 1:1

Penalty

2004

Aston Villa vs Newcastle United 4:2

Aston Villa vs Queens Park Rangers 3:1

Blackburn Rovers vs Aston Villa 2:2

Burnley FC vs Aston Villa 3:1

Aston Villa vs Portsmouth FC 3:0

Fulham FC vs Aston Villa 1:1

Aston Villa vs Arsenal FC 1:3

Right-footed shot

Newcastle United vs Aston Villa 0:3

Right-footed shot

Aston Villa vs Manchester City 1:2

2005

Bolton Wanderers vs Aston Villa 1:1

Aston Villa vs Everton FC 4:0

Wigan Athletic vs Aston Villa 3:2

2006

Aston Villa vs Reading FC 2:1

Penalty

Aston Villa vs Newcastle United 2:0

Scunthorpe United vs Aston Villa 1:2

Leicester City vs Aston Villa 2:3 AET

Aston Villa vs Blackburn Rovers 2:0

Portsmouth FC vs Aston Villa 2:2

No information

New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew 4:0

Right-footed shot

New York Red Bulls vs Chicago Fire 3:0

Right-footed shot

Right-footed shot

Kansas City Wizards vs New York Red Bulls 3:2

Right-footed shot

Toronto FC vs New York Red Bulls 1:2

Direct free kick

Left-footed shot

D.C. United vs New York Red Bulls 4:2

Right-footed shot

New York Red Bulls vs Kansas City Wizards 3:3

Header

Penalty

New York Red Bulls vs Toronto FC 3:0

Right-footed shot

New York Red Bulls vs Los Angeles Galaxy 5:4

Direct free kick

Right-footed shot

D.C. United vs New York Red Bulls 3:1

Penalty

New York Red Bulls vs Chicago Fire 1:0

Right-footed shot

Chicago Fire vs New York Red Bulls 2:2

Penalty

New York Red Bulls vs New England Revolution 2:2

Right-footed shot

New York Red Bulls vs Real Salt Lake City 2:2

Penalty

New York Red Bulls vs Kansas City Wizards 2:1

Penalty

Right-footed shot

2011

CD Chivas USA Reserves vs Seattle Sounders FC Reserves 3:4

Penalty

No information

CD Chivas USA vs Chicago Fire 1:2

Penalty

New York Red Bulls vs CD Chivas USA 1:1

Right-footed shot

Carolina RailHawks FC vs CD Chivas USA 1:2

Penalty

CD Chivas USA vs Montreal Impact 2:1

Header

Colorado Rapids vs CD Chivas USA 1:1

Right-footed shot

2019

Club Alianza Lima vs Club Atlético River Plate 1:1

Club Sporting Cristal vs Club Atlético River Plate 2:3

Club Atlético River Plate vs Club Atlético Colón 4:1

Club Atlético River Plate vs Club Atlético Colón 2:1

Club Atlético Colón vs Club Atlético River Plate 1:3

2020

Atlético Nacional vs Alianza Petrolera 5:1

Atlético Nacional vs Asociación Deportivo Pasto 1:1

Uniautónoma FC vs Atlético Nacional 0:3

Header

Right-footed shot

Asociación Deportivo Pasto vs Atlético Nacional 2:1